Friday, August 8, 2014

The Key Work of School Boards: School Board President Response to Chapter 2 - Vision

The Key Work of School Boards:  School Board President Response to Chapter 2 - Vision

I discussed the Vision Self-Assessment questions with our local school board president.  The majority of the questions were answered as “mostly achieved.”   Two of the questions received a “fully achieved” rating.  One question received a “partially achieved” rating and one question received a “beginning to achieve” rating.
The district has established a written vision/mission that commits to student achievement as the top priority of the school board.  These statements are posted on the school website and are clearly displayed in large poster format in each district school building. 

When establishing district goals, the board enlisted an outside facilitator who gathered two major groupings to supply the board with input.  The first group was made up of school staff.  The second group included members of the community.  Out of these groups the board formalized seven district goals:

1) Increase rigor and accountability in academics
Goal: Investigate better ways to measure student learning & achievement (skill- based or competency-based report cards?)
2) Building & facilities plans
Goal: Work toward a successful referendum in November.
3) Clear guidance & expectations from administrators
Goal: Provide regular communication from superintendent & administrators to all staff & community members.
4) Focus and time to implement programs and goals year after year
Goals: 4A) The administrative team will create a 2013-14 school year professional development schedule.
4B) The administrator who supervises the employee will meet with that employee to find what they can "take off their plates."
5) Develop a strong PreK-12 reading program
Goal: Pursue optional funding to implement, support & enhance a research proven effective reading program.
6) Incorporate Spanish as a "special"
Goal: Develop a PreK-6 introductory level foreign language program for FY15
& provide 30 minutes of instruction per week for PreK-6 students.
7) Increase respect at all levels
Goals: 7A) Complete building-level surveys to ID morale issues & develop improvements through SIT.
7B) Research & select a data-gathering tool to measure student bullying.

Although the school board president believes that the board is aligning all of its decisions toward the achievement of the vision and goals, he also stated that the board does not revisit the vision and goals frequently.

I believe that the current school board approached the work of establishing board goals with the best of intentions.  However, there appears to be confusion in the need to establish/revisit vision, mission and goals.  The vision and mission were established many years ago and have not been revisited by the board any time recently for review.  The work that was done to establish board goals, however, was done with several groups of stakeholders involved.  This was done shortly after the first building referendum failed which is probably why one of the goals includes mention of passing a building referendum.

My suggestions for improvement?  Show the school board how a continuous improvement plan is done elsewhere.  Allow the school board to decide on a method that they believe will be effective in Arcadia.  Develop a schedule for implementing the plan and put this information in the eye of the public.  Keep everything as transparent as possible!  As the plan is proceeding – keep putting the results in the eye of the public.  Do the same when the plan is completed.  Also plan for regular updates and follow through with the plan.  This will bring the vision and the goals that support the vision to the forefront of board discussions on a regular basis.

Connections: School Board Governance, Student Performance, and District Vision

Connections:  School Board Governance, Student Performance, and District Vision

The framework of school board governance provides a strong relationship between district vision/purpose and student performance.  In a school district that functions within this model, the school board is required to set goals for the district.  In a high-functioning school district, the board would determine these goals through a direct link with the community.  After determining the values of the community towards the education of its students, the board would develop goals that reflect these values.  Most likely, one of the goals that will be set will involve increased learning for the students.  This goal will now filter through the layers of accountability within the school district, starting with the superintendent, flowing next to the school building principals, and then being a required goal for the teachers of the students.

After going to training on SLO’s this past week, I can see how having clear district level goals that tie to student achievement could be very helpful to everyone involved.  If the school board has made it clear that increased student achievement is expected, the principals can use that goal as a guide in establishing a building-level SLO.  It may also be possible for the teaching staff to do the same – using the building-level SLO as a guide in establishing their individual professional SLO’s.


Several of the principals that attended the SLO training were discussing the need to require their teachers to set an SLO that addressed reading or literacy.  Again, this becomes much easier to require if the school board has set a goal that supports that requirement.